Antinomia
A contradiction between two laws or principles — the tension when equally valid rules yield opposite conclusions in the same case.
The Meaning of Antinomia
Antinomia captured the Greek perception that law (nomos) was not a seamless system but a field of genuine conflicts. The most celebrated dramatization of antinomia was Sophocles's Antigone, in which the divine law requiring burial of the dead (backed by Zeus and Hades) directly collided with Creon's civic law prohibiting burial of traitors. Neither law was simply wrong — both expressed real obligations — yet they were mutually exclusive. The play refused to dissolve the conflict cleanly, making antinomia the structural principle of the tragedy. In philosophical usage, Protagoras's argument that every question had two sides (dissoi logoi) institutionalized antinomia as a rhetorical and analytical method. Later, Kant borrowed the term for his famous antinomies of pure reason — pairs of propositions about the universe that could be demonstrated both true and false — acknowledging the Greek origin of the problem.
Parents
{}
Children
{}
Symbols
Fun Fact
Kant's four antinomies — some of the most famous problems in Western philosophy — take their name and their structure directly from Greek legal vocabulary.
Words We Inherited
English words and phrases that trace back to this myth. See our full guide to English words from Greek mythology.
Explore Further
Nomos
💭 conceptlaw, custom, convention
Human-made law and custom, as opposed to the natural order (physis).
Dikē
💭 conceptreligion, ethics, law
Justice, right order, or the way things ought to be — both the divine personification of justice and the principle of cosmic and social rightness.
Polemos
💭 conceptphilosophy, mythology
War or conflict — personified as a deity and understood by Heraclitus as the fundamental generating principle of all existence.
Draconian
💭 conceptHarsh laws, severe punishment, rigid authority
Excessively harsh or severe, from Draco, the Athenian lawgiver whose code prescribed death for nearly every offence.
Republic
💭 conceptLiterature
Plato's philosophical dialogue exploring justice, the ideal state, and the nature of the soul
Divine Justice
💭 conceptEthics
The principle that the gods punish wrongdoing and uphold moral order in the cosmos
Enantiodromia
💭 conceptphilosophy
The tendency of extremes to reverse into their opposites — the principle that things carried to their limit swing back toward what they denied.
Aeschylus
💭 conceptTragedy, justice, divine law
Father of Greek tragedy who introduced the second actor and composed the Oresteia trilogy
Goddess of Justice
💭 conceptJustice, law, moral order, custom
Themis upholds divine law and natural order, counselling Zeus on what is right and presiding over assemblies.
Asebeia
💭 conceptreligion, law
Impiety — the crime of failing to honor the gods properly, disrespecting sacred things, or introducing foreign religious practices.
Aporia
💭 conceptThe productive state of philosophical puzzlement
The state of intellectual impasse that Socrates deliberately induced — the recognition that you do not know what you thought you knew.
Nomos basileus
💭 conceptphilosophy, law
Law is king — the principle that law, not any individual ruler, holds supreme authority; the Greek foundation of the rule of law concept.